A disgrace to BSG - Gregory Bartz - San Jose, CA
Sometime toward the end of Season 3, the showrunners of the new BSG had started to lose track of what they were doing; season 4 saw the series painfully collapse under the weight of its own mythology, with the writers unable to come up with a more satisfying conclusion to the story than "God did it and the characters are angels". "The Plan" is the recycled vomit of that mythology, explaining things that were better left unexplained while failing to explain the things that really needed to be clarified. And, as can be expected from a group of people who had completely lost track of what they were doing, it contradicts previous canon. If the Cyclons' "Plan" was little more than "exterminate humanity", then why did the phrase "And they have a plan" continue to appear during the opening for season 3, during which the Cylons wanted to peacefully coexist with humanity and find Earth? All of this, plus a total lack of emotional depth, make "The Plan" a disgrace to the new BSG.
Best of the Battlestar movies - D. Porter - Coeur d'Alene, ID
For me this movie was more engaging than either Razor or Caprica. The plot line and acting had more depth. Like all the movies, one has to be familiar with the series to fully comprehend what is going on, but as an adjunct to the series I think it added better understanding to the evolution of the Cylons as the war progressed.
As a director, Olmos is a fine actor. - Richard Walden - Portland, OR
If you're a BSG fan, you're going to watch this, regardless of what anyone says. If you're NOT a BSG fan, steer clear of this, go watch season 1. Battlestar Galactica - Season One
There is actually an interesting story in here, that if you're a fan, you have to watch. (that's right, have to...it's an order)
Be warned though, that there is way too much recycled footage, the pacing feels wooden and pedantic, and in his directorial debut, Edward James Olmos proves which side of the camera he belongs on.
0 comments:
Post a Comment